STEEL IN INFRASTRUCTURE
: FOR A BETTER TOMORROW (JUNE 2000)
- By Sandip Pal & Dr. S.R. Mediratta
Sandip Pal
is Manager (Civil & Struc.),and Dr.S R Mediratta, is Director
General Institute for Steel Development & Growth (INSDAG), Calcutta
Infrastructure development’ is one of the oldest priorities of mankind.
Probably it started with the efforts of bush cleaning and shelter building
by Adam and Eve, and continued its efforts over the past thousands of
years to justify its role in the modern world. Starting from the ancient
landmarks like the massive Pyramids, the Great Wall of China or the
Grand Trunk Road between Calcutta and Peshawar during the period of
Sher Shah; to the recent marvels like the Lincoln Highway (USA), Trans-Siberian
Railway (Russia), Patronas Tower (Malaysia) or Akashi Kaikyo Bridge
(Japan), ‘Infrastructure’ has always been the lifeline of human prosperity.
Technical breakthroughs, global opportunities and private funding have
revolutionized the modern ‘infrastructure development’. Indian economy,
with a growth rate of 6-6.8% and a growth potential of 7-8% in coming
years is one of the emerging mega powers in today’s world. At the same
time, attracting precious foreign direct investment and ‘fast track
infrastructure development’ remain the most challenging task before
the country, given the changed techno-economic scenario, liberalization
of economy and the global competition.
The approach towards ‘infrastructure development’ has become more professional
and modern concepts of steel- intensive construction are the subject
of interest in India nowadays. Greatly influenced by: BOT/ BOOT mode
of contracts; FDI and private funding; fast track buildability; availability
of modern equipment; quality-driven output; social and environmental
accountability, infrastructure construction will never be the same again.
And under the changed scenario steel with its immense potential is becoming
the preferred material of construction to most of the Indian designers,
architects, builders and owners.
India and its Infrastructure: an Overview
The spectrum of infrastructure covers almost all the areas of modern
construction be it housing and buildings; highways and railways; airports
and seaports; power and telecommunication; industry and defence; flood
and drought control; sports and medical facilities; and finally urban
and rural development.
In the post liberalization era (after 1991-92), there has been a tremendous
need for total infrastructure revolution. Though a basic necessity,
agriculture is no longer the driving force of the economy. Industrialization,
urbanization and faster modes of transport etc are on the upsurge. During
the last 50 years, population of India has grown 2.5 times but urban
India (2nd largest in the world) has grown by 5 times. Today, 30 crore
people live in about 3700 towns scattered all over India and one third
of this urban population live in about 40 metropolitan cities (with
million plus population).
The Road Ahead
To meet the urgent and demanding requirements, a lot needs to be done
in terms of infrastructure development for ensuring the basic amenities
and improving the quality of life. The 9th Plan Working Group on Housing
has estimated the investment for urban housing at Rs.52,600 crores.
The India Infrastructure report, 1996 estimates the annual investment
need for urban water supply, sanitation and roads at Rs. 28,035 crores
for the next ten years. The Central Public Health Engineering has estimated
the funds requirement for safe water supply/ sanitation for 100 % coverage
of the urban population by 2021 at Rs. 1,72,905 crores. Estimates by
M/s RITES indicate that the amount required for urban transport infrastructure
investment in cities with population 100,000 or more during the next
20 years would be of the order of Rs. 207,000 crore.
As a part of the shelter component of the national agenda, the Government
has estimated that there is a shortage of 13 lakh houses in the rural
and 7 lakh in the urban areas in the country, which will require about
Rs 4,000 crores. In the power sector there are about 160 private power
projects totalling about 67000 MW capacity (approx. Rs 268,000 Crores)
at various stages of clearances / execution.
The ambitious national highways development project (Rakesh Mohan Report,
June ’96) envisages time and cost- bound implementation of around 36,000
Kms of roadwork over a period of 10 years at an estimated cost of Rs
80200 Crores (‘96 price). This includes the Golden Quadrilateral project
(5952 km), the North-South-East-West corridor project (7300 km), about
500 new bridges, 40 bypasses and 2000 km expressways along with widening
of existing highways, Sums of above magnitudes cannot be sourced from
within the budgetary resources of any Government. Heavy dependence on
borrowed capital, and necessity for permitting private/ foreign participation
in infrastructure projects will require speedy implementation without
time and cost overrun. To achieve this goal, like most of the developed
countries, which have solid infrastructure base, we need to adopt the
steel intensive or steel-concrete composite construction route. The
per capita consumption of steel in India is only 27 kgs, whereas the
same is about 15 times higher in USA and about 45 times higher in Singapore.
The Steel Route: Myths and Realities
Steel members with their design flexibility, easy buildability, factory-made
quality, ductility, upgrade-ability and broader architectural possibility
have immense potential as the preferred construction material in modern
India. Meeting serviceability requirements, restoration after disaster
damage/ accidents, upgradation of structure due to revised loading standards
and replacement of structures at the end of service life are much easier
with steel. While steel construction has dominated in the early years,
other modes of construction have taken over in the past few years in
some sectors. But, steel is still dominant in almost all the industrial
structures and construction in remote areas. For longer span construction
also, steel is the only alternative. Fortunately, some of the new urban
constructions in India have followed the steel route too. The ICICI
building (Mumbai), VSNL Tower (Calcutta), some of the flyovers at Calcutta,
Mumbai and Delhi are only a few examples, while a lot more are in the
pipeline.
Steel too has come a long way today and some of the old myths about
steel are no longer valid. It is now statistically and otherwise established
that the life-span, protection and maintenance of steel structures are
comfortably comparable with and in many instances much superior to any
other mode of construction. Better quality (high tensile / corrosion
resistant/ alloyed etc) and wider variety (rolled and built-up sections
/ cold formed/ profiled / colour coated sheet / stainless steel / wire
ropes etc) steels are easily available today. Import of steel is also
possible. Technology for protection of steel is much advanced today
and paint systems are available to provide maintenance–free life of
about 20-25 years. The design codes are being revised and slowly, the
steel construction industry is also building up. The Western Experience
Developed economies in the world are taking maximum advantage from increased
usage of steel in construction. For example in the UK today, more than
90% of single storey buildings are steel framed and about half of these
are portal frames. In multi-storey buildings also, share of steel in
the UK, as measured by floor area, has reached a level of 60% against
<30% about 15 years ago. As regards commercial buildings, in 1991-92
steelwork construction in the UK had a market share of 59%, in Sweden
of 50% and in Netherlands 26%. In industrial buildings, the market share
of steelwork construction is reported to be between 77 and 92% in the
UK, Sweden, Netherlands, Spain, Belgium and France. The situation in
USA and Japan is almost similar. Steel is widely used in framing, flooring,
walling and roofing in residential/ commercial buildings of single/
multi-storey construction. Pre-fabricated buildings and space structures
are also commonly used. Fast-build composite construction and slim floor
techniques have revolutionized the floor-slab construction. Steel-intensive/
steel-concrete composite bridges became preferred options since the
mid-eighties after the publication of BS 5400 codes. In UK today, 35%
of total bridges built in 15-20 m span are composite construction. Strategies
for India The future for steel intensive construction is promising and
steel can be effectively used in various areas of buildings, bridges
and other structures. With steep rise in the land-price and population
density, cities are growing vertically and new generation steel multi-storeys
seem to be the future in the congested metros. Fast build modular construction
and prefabricated buildings can save construction time up to 40% and
are suitable for both urban and rural applications. Composite flyovers
and bridges at crowded metros and busy highways can be cost-effective
solutions, the trend of which has already started. Even minor items
like steel crash barriers and handrails over flyovers/ bridges, and
steel guardrails and elevated road sign arrangements over modern highways/
expressways at regular intervals are now coming up. Steel intensive
multi-storyed car parks can provide quick solutions to one of the biggest
problems of congested metros. Cities of Mumbai, Delhi and Bangalore
are building rail based Mass Rapid Transit Systems to take care of much
of their urban traffic problem and steel intensive construction can
provide the best possible solution (e,g Docklands Light Railway, UK).
Railways are the single largest consumers of steel (more than one million
tonne per year) in India and steel intensive construction/ application
has its own place there. For structures ranging from airport and seaport
to warehouses and water pipelines, stadiums and shopping plazas, pedestrian
bridges and enabling structures, steel can be the most preferred material
of construction in all the areas. Life cycle cost assessment route can
be an important criteria for decision-making during infrastructure project
evaluation by the project owners (and project partners), justifying
the full worth of steel - intensive construction and ensuring minimum
disruption to the public life. The present is however tough sailing
and needs proper vision and catalytic efforts for the much needed multiplier
effect. The exposure and proper awareness about today’s possibilities
of steel is rather less among a major part of owners, specifiers, designers
and builders. Unlike the BS or Euro Codes, IS/ IRC design Codes lack
in proper focus in limit state approach for true cost effectiveness.
Efficient sections like parallel/ wide flange beams and jumbo sections
(including their high strength variety) are still not manufactured in
India. In fact, availability and application of high strength/ weather
resistant grade steel and a wider range of efficient sections as mentioned
above needs focused attention from all the corners. Proper development
of well-organized small and medium sized fabricator sector and the high-build
paint sector (for protection and fire resistance) is another important
area. The Government and steel manufacturers have also their share of
role to play. Fortunately, initiatives have been taken in all the above
areas including the code revision, awareness drive and training. To
Conclude Speedy infrastructure development will not only provide the
basic support to the economy, but will also reshape the feature of India.
Steel and steel intensive construction is the future of tomorrow’s infrastructure.
It is a reality in the developed countries, what have already passed
the phase that India is currently sailing through. With the massive
drive in today’s infrastructure building, steel consumption in infrastructure
sector will definitely go up. And tomorrow’s skyline will be dominated
by steel, the most preferred material of construction by today’s designers
and builders. Let’us build the nation with nerves and bones of steel!